My Best Eyebrow Mascaras – RANKING

brow mascara ranking

Hey there! Dear readers, are there any women here looking for a good brow mascara? I know that you like this type of product as it ensures you can quickly and easily increase the volume of your eyebrows and add definition. In addition, eyebrow mascaras are products that have beautifying and conditioning properties. How to choose the best one that makes your eyebrows dazzle? You can test different options, or… check out my best eyebrow mascara ranking! 😀 It’s created especially for you, so hope you enjoy it! 

How does a good brow mascara work?

Eyebrow mascara is a fantastic product for anyone who wants to keep their brows in place and give them the right shape and a thicker look. The makeup will make the arches more defined and captivating. Eyebrow mascara shades should also be refined to emphasize the eyebrow color. And let’s not forget the conditioning effect some eyebrow mascaras have. They contain ingredients like hyaluronic acid, oils, biotin, or panthenol, which benefit brow hairs and skin around the eyebrows. Thanks to them, your eyebrows will not only look beautiful but also be in great condition!

How to apply eyebrow mascara?

To get the effect of full eyebrows, eyebrow mascara should be applied to dry brows after applying your moisturizer or foundation. The brush should be held in an outward direction, gently aiming upward. If necessary, of course, you can add another coat of mascara, provided it comes with a good brush that doesn’t leave any clumps. 

Good brow-thickening mascara – which one to choose?

There are, of course, plenty of makeup products available on the market, but trust my ranking. This way, you won’t have to look any further!  Here, you are sure to find something suitable for yourself. How to choose the best brow mascara? It’s easy! First of all, pay attention to the product’s shade. Choose a brow mascara that is as close as possible to the natural color of your eyebrows. For everyday wear, you can use a product a shade darker than the natural color of your brows. When you create evening makeup, the shade of the eyebrow mascara can be slightly darker. But remember to avoid an overdrawn brow look using mascara that’s too dark for your arches.

Another important fact is the quality of a particular product. Choose eyebrow mascara that, above all, is efficient to avoid having to get another one soon. It is important to always check whether the eyebrow mascara is not only effective but also safe for the eyes. Prices can also influence the product choice but beware – low price can mean poor quality brow mascara. You do not have to overpay – products at more expensive prices are practically no different from those at slightly lower ones. I came across brow mascaras that are both affordable and high quality. Of course, I included them in my ranking!

My best brow mascaras – RANKING

1. NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA 

best brow mascara for thin brows
  • QUALITY 10/10
  • PRICE 10/10
  • MAKEUP EFFECTS 10/10
  • DURABILITY: 9/10 (this is not a waterproof eyebrow mascara, but it’s still incredibly long-wear)! 

I must admit that I didn’t think I would come across a beauty game-changer of such high quality at such a great price! This brow mascara is really special. You may already know the Nanobrow brand, which specializes precisely in makeup and eyebrow care products. Its gorgeous mascara proves the brand knows how to define your brows and make them look healthy and stunning! This brow mascara comes with a great brush, that’s very comfortable to use and very precise. Using it, you can not only create makeup for everyday wear but also bolder brow looks for special events! You simply need to apply 2 or 3 coats of the mascara and the whole makeup gains extra definition. Nanobrow Shape Mascara is very long-wear, so you can rest assured about your makeup looking good all day, plus it comes in lovely shades that are sure to appeal to all women, regardless of their brow color and skin tone.

2. DIOR DIORSHOW ON SET BROW MASCARA

  • QUALITY 10/10
  • PRICE 9/10
  • MAKEUP EFFECTS 9/10
  • DURABILITY 9/10

If we are talking about fashionable beauty products promoted by famous designers, I am definitely in favor of the Dior brand. Although, price-wise these products do not do that well and their eyebrow mascara simply costs a fortune. The nice thing about it is that it features high quality and contains up to 90% naturally derived ingredients. In addition, it conditions the brows quite nicely and the makeup you can create with it looks pretty decent too. You have four shades to choose from, so there is a brow mascara for blondes and brunettes. However, I must add that the brown brow mascara shade has slightly warm undertones so it won’t be suitable for everyone. 

3. LANCOME SOURCILS STYLER

  • QUALITY 10/10
  • PRICE 9/10
  • MAKEUP EFFECTS 9/10
  • DURABILITY 9/10

My ranking of the best eyebrow mascaras is filled mostly by very well-known and recommended products with high quality but unfortunately, as you can see, many of them come at a high price. Are they worth investing in? Of course, the choice is up to you. As you can see, this time it is not a cheap brow mascara either, although it is worth noting that it comes in a larger size so at least it should be more efficient and last for longer. The mascara has an interesting brush, which nicely sets and styles the brows. Unfortunately, it doesn’t give them much volume or definition. I think you will find this eyebrow mascara more useful as a finishing touch to your makeup. It works well with an eyebrow pomade or a pencil. Its durability may not appeal to everyone either.

4. BENEFIT GIMME BROW MASCARA

  • QUALITY 9/10
  • PRICE 9/10 
  • MAKEUP EFFECTS 8/10 
  • DURABILITY 9/10

Although it’s not cheap brow mascara, perhaps the smaller version will already be on everyone’s budget. But is it worth buying this eyebrow mascara knowing the brush doesn’t work that well for separating brow hairs? Instead, it glues them together and creates a very defined brow makeup. Well… personally, I have to tell you that this mascara didn’t quite work on my brows but I have noticed that owners of thick, but not very expressive eyebrows are very keen on this mascara. This is a brow mascara with fibers. They should give brows a thicker look and make them more voluminous. However, my brows felt overburdened but my friend’s eyebrows looked really nice after applying this brow mascara. The effect was satisfactory so I decided to include it in my ranking of the best eyebrow mascaras.

5. URBAN DECAY BROW MASCARA ENDOWED

  • QUALITY 8/10
  • PRICE 8/10
  • MAKEUP EFFECTS 9/10
  • DURABILITY 8/10

Ladies… I don’t really know quite what to think about this brow mascara. Its price is quite high and the size is small as the brand decided to create a double-sided product that has the brow mascara on one side and a transparent gel on the other, which in my opinion is completely useless., The mascara should keep the brows in place so you should not need any gel at all to boost the effect. Economically, it doesn’t seem like the best option as you get just half the product. The product runs out quickly but it works quite well though. Personally, I was satisfied with the effect: my brow makeup with this mascara looked decent. Durability is okay too, I can’t complain about it, although at the end of the day, the mascara wore off a bit only on one eyebrow, which gave an asymmetrical and unprofessional effect. 

Eyebrow mascara – price. How much should you pay for a good brow mascara?

I think my beauty ranking has made it clear that the prices of eyebrow mascaras vary depending on the brand and quality of the product. The cheapest brow mascaras are affordable but their quality can unfortunately be debatable. However, my ranking proved that a good eyebrow mascara does not have to cost a fortune at all!

Eyebrow mascara shades – how to choose the right one? 

When choosing the best eyebrow mascara shade for yourself, you must pay attention to your hair and eyebrow colors. Their shade should be the best clue. A good eyebrow mascara should emphasize your natural beauty and enhance your personal charm 🙂 Therefore, to achieve a natural effect, choose a shade lighter than the natural color of your brows. Who can use a tinted brow mascara? Reach for it if: your eyebrows lack definition, you want to give them a thicker look and highlight and enhance their color, as well as style and fix your brow hairs to create elegant and neat eyebrow makeup.


I hope my best eyebrow mascara ranking helped you make your choice and now you can find the best brow mascara for yourself. Let me know which one it is! Hugs!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *